Understanding the dynamics of volcanic eruptions requires constraints on the processes of melt extraction in shallow magma reservoirs. This study focuses on the formation of intraplutonic igneous layering known as comb layers and orbicules within the Fisher Lake Pluton, Sierra Nevada. Comb layers are mineralogically and texturally diverse, ranging from plagioclase‐amphibole comb layers to plagioclase‐pyroxene and olivine comb layers. The majority of individual layers are related to the initiation of plagioclase nucleation and growth on preexisting host rocks and remobilized xenoliths. We use simple phase diagrams to illustrate the formation of comb layers through crystal fractionation along conduit walls and xenoliths, with plagioclase as the liquidus phase. Near‐adiabatic ascent of water‐undersaturated melts through the crust will lead to superheating and crystal resorption, which upon saturation of volatiles at shallow depth can induce heterogeneous nucleation of plagioclase. The rarity of orbicules and comb layers worldwide suggests that adiabatic decompression of crystal‐poor, moderately hydrous melts through the crust is rare. Most melts in intermediate/silicic volcanoes crystallize in multiple reservoirs within the crust prior to emplacement at shallow depth as crystal‐bearing melts. Comb layers and orbicules preserve evidence of multiple melt injections where a sequence of texturally and mineralogically similar comb layers and orbicules reflect the timescale of an individual melt pulse. Short timescales on the order of months to years for the growth of these sequences are estimated using experimental plagioclase growth rates and are interpreted as representing the lifetime of a melt injection within a long‐lived, subvolcanic melt extraction zone.