“…Genetic methods also use more direct approaches, e.g., based on parentage analyses, but these are applicable only when a very significant fraction of individuals can be sampled (Gagnaire et al, 2015), which in effect happens in only very particular systems, and certainly not in the deep-sea. Surprisingly, although it has been proposed for many years as a tool to study larval dispersal (Levin, 1990;Levin et al, 1993), and has been widely used in coastal environments (Zacherl et al, 2003;Becker et al, 2005Becker et al, , 2007Carson, 2010;Fodrie et al, 2011;Kroll et al, 2016;Honig et al, 2020;Bounket et al, 2021), the alternative approach of elemental fingerprinting of biogenic carbonate structures (such as otoliths or shells) has never been used in deep-sea species (Baco et al, 2016;Cunha et al, 2020). The success of this approach relies on the record in calcified structures of the chemical composition of the water in which they have been built (e.g., Thorrold et al 2007).…”