Calcium-binding stoichiometry, dissociation equilibrium constants at zero ionic strength @Lo), and molar extinction difference coefficients (At,) at the wavelength )r of the metallochromic indicators arsenazo I (ArsI) and tetramethylmurexide (TMX) were reevaluated with a computerized method based on mass conservation and thermodynamic consistency checks. This new method is shown to provide a more critical assessment of the assumed calcium-dye complexing model than is afforded by the commonly used reciprocal-plot method. The analyses of spectrophotometric Ca titrations confirm that both dyes form only 1: 1 complexes in aqueous solution. For TMX, R" = 1.3 X lOA3 hp and At&,, = 1.5 X I@ M-' cm-'; for Arsl, R" = 5.8 X 10el M and A6562 = 1.8 X 104 M-' cm-' at pH '7.0 and T = 293OK. The discriminatory power of the analytical method is demonstrated by comparison of these results with those found for a different dye, arsenazo III, which complexes Ca in l:l, 1:2, and 2:l forms.