Photoluminescence (PL) quenching
by gold nanoparticles (AuNPs)
is a frequently applied principle in nanobiosensing. The quenching
is most often explained in terms of the Förster resonance energy-transfer
(FRET) mechanism, and more rarely in terms of the nanosurface energy-transfer
(NSET) mechanism. Although both consider nonradiative resonance energy
transfer, there are significant differences in predictions of the
strength and the distance-dependence of the quenching. Here, we investigate
the energy transfer to AuNPs from a terbium(III)-complex (Tb) with
a long (millisecond) PL decay time with the aim to provide a better
understanding of the underlying energy-transfer process. The binding
of Tb-labeled streptavidin (Tb-sAv) to biotinylated AuNPs (biot-AuNPs)
was studied using light-scattering spectroscopy. Quenching of the
PL of Tb-sAv upon binding to biot-AuNPs of different diameters (5,
30, 50, 80 nm) was studied by time-resolved PL spectroscopy. Energy-transfer
efficiencies were found to be practically independent of the AuNP
size. Analysis according to FRET theory yielded donor–acceptor
distances that were inconsistent and far beyond the expected Tb–AuNP
distance. In contrast, the NSET model yielded a good agreement between
the Tb-to-AuNP surface distance estimated from the geometry of the
Tb-sAv/biotin-AuNP assembly (4.5 nm) and those calculated from PL
lifetime analysis, which range from 4.0 to 6.3 nm. Our findings strongly
suggest that NSET (and not FRET) is the operational mechanism in PL
quenching by AuNPs, which is important information for the development,
characterization, and application of nanobiosensors based on PL quenching
by AuNPs.