Speech entrainment enables patients with Broca's aphasia to produce fluent speech

Abstract

A distinguishing feature of Broca's aphasia is non-fluent halting speech typically involving one to three words per utterance. Yet, despite such profound impairments, some patients can mimic audio-visual speech stimuli enabling them to produce fluent speech in real time. We call this effect 'speech entrainment' and reveal its neural mechanism as well as explore its usefulness as a treatment for speech production in Broca's aphasia. In Experiment 1, 13 patients with Broca's aphasia were tested in three conditions: (i) speech entrainment with audio-visual feedback where they attempted to mimic a speaker whose mouth was seen on an iPod screen; (ii) speech entrainment with audio-only feedback where patients mimicked heard speech; and (iii) spontaneous speech where patients spoke freely about assigned topics. The patients produced a greater variety of words using audio-visual feedback compared with audio-only feedback and spontaneous speech. No difference was found between audio-only feedback and spontaneous speech. In Experiment 2, 10 of the 13 patients included in Experiment 1 and 20 control subjects underwent functional magnetic resonance imaging to determine the neural mechanism that supports speech entrainment. Group results with patients and controls revealed greater bilateral cortical activation for speech produced during speech entrainment compared with spontaneous speech at the junction of the anterior insula and Brodmann area 47, in Brodmann area 37, and unilaterally in the left middle temporal gyrus and the dorsal portion of Broca's area. Probabilistic white matter tracts constructed for these regions in the normal subjects revealed a structural network connected via the corpus callosum and ventral fibres through the extreme capsule. Unilateral areas were connected via the arcuate fasciculus. In Experiment 3, all patients included in Experiment 1 participated in a 6-week treatment phase using speech entrainment to improve speech production. Behavioural and functional magnetic resonance imaging data were collected before and after the treatment phase. Patients were able to produce a greater variety of words with and without speech entrainment at 1 and 6 weeks after training. Treatment-related decrease in cortical activation associated with speech entrainment was found in areas of the left posterior-inferior parietal lobe. We conclude that speech entrainment allows patients with Broca's aphasia to double their speech output compared with spontaneous speech. Neuroimaging results suggest that speech entrainment allows patients to produce fluent speech by providing an external gating mechanism that yokes a ventral language network that encodes conceptual aspects of speech. Preliminary results suggest that training with speech entrainment improves speech production in Broca's aphasia providing a potential therapeutic method for a disorder that has been shown to be particularly resistant to treatment.

Choral singing therapy following stroke or Parkinson’s disease: an exploration of participants’ experiences

“…Participants described how they watched the choir leader for cues, and used group flow and rhythm to entrain to melody and words; similar to other therapies suggested for Broca's aphasia and dysarthria [95,96]. This lends support for rhythm as a therapeutic agent in music [18,97], rhythmic cueing for word production in song [36], and the benefits of singing in synchrony with an auditory model (provided by the choir and choir leader) [98].…”

Revealing the dual streams of speech processing

“…The PNT was scored for correct naming in addition to failed naming attempts that included phonological and semantic errors. In addition to published tests, this study relied on a sentence comprehension test involving various different sentence types (47) as well as analyses of spoken errors during reading (Grandfather Passage) (48), discourse (picture description), and speech entrainment (49). Finally, a large proportion of the participants completed an "in-house" test that involved verbal naming of pictures depicting 80 mid-to high-frequency nouns (50).…”

Intervenções em afasia: uma revisão integrativa

“…In studies of Hamilton et al 37 and Martin et al 38 , the stimulation protocols were applied in three subjects (one and two, respectively) with chronic aphasia (more than a year). The results were significant for the improvement of the language in the case of the study in 2010 and for one of the participants of the study in 2009, indicating that the same protocol may not produce the improvement of language for all patients, depending mainly of injured areas, issue discussed by Martin, et al 38 , and indicated in the Sarasso et al 18 , Fridriksson et al 21 and Fridriksson et al 22 studies. Jung et al 29 and Naeser et al 39 aimed to study the rehabilitation of speech in a case of Global Aphasia with the right dominant hemisphere, and non-fluent Aphasia associated with sleep apnea.…”

“…The study of Fridriksson et al 21 examined changes in cerebral activation after training with different to increase the generality of these results and better understand the correlations and benefits found.…”