Spirituality and hearing voices: considering the relation

Abstract

For millennia, some people have heard voices that others cannot hear. These have been variously understood as medical, psychological and spiritual phenomena. In this article we consider the specific role of spirituality in voice-hearing in two ways. First, we examine how spirituality may help or hinder people who hear voices. Benefits are suggested to include offering an alternative meaning to the experience which can give more control and comfort, enabling the development of specific coping strategies, increasing social support, and encouraging forgiveness. Potential drawbacks are noted to include increased distress and reduced control resulting from placing frightening or coercive constructions on voices, social isolation, the development of dysfunctional beliefs, and missed/delayed opportunities for successful mental health interventions. After examining problems surrounding classifying voices as either spiritual or psychotic, we move beyond an essentialist position to examine how such a classification is likely to be fluid, and how a given voice may move between these designations. We also highlight tensions between modernist and postmodernist approaches to voice-hearing.

Emerging Perspectives From the Hearing Voices Movement: Implications for Research and Practice

“…This is consistent with widely held cultural beliefs about voices 19 and with beliefs held by people in community samples who experience voice-hearing without a need for psychiatric help. 20 …”

Narrative insight in psychosis: The relationship with spiritual and religious explanatory frameworks

“…There is a discussion about the extent to which experiences labelled as psychotic and those labelled as spiritual can be distinguished (e.g., Jackson, ; Jackson & Fulford, ; McCarthy‐Jones, Waegeli, & Watkins, 2013). The suggestion is that the underlying psychological correlates of either experience would be similar, with the only difference being in the manner in which they affect the individual's life.…”

Hearing Voices, Demonic and Divine

“…It is intense and after hearing it I feel tired. (McCarthy-Jones et al, 2013) Whilst it is helpful and important to know that voice hearers such as Waegeli make such distinction, it is less clear that such distinctions are either helpful or possible when made by researchers or clinicians. For example, Myrtle Heery has studied 30 subjects 4 reporting "inner voice experiences" and has classified their interview transcripts according to three categories:…”