We report a case of a 69 year old right handed female, presents to Emergency Room (ER) with sudden onset right hemiparesis, within 90 minutes. She also had nagging neck pain since the start of this weakness. Her examination showed dense right hemiplegia with minimal involvement of face, her initial CT brain was unremarkable. As she was within therapeutic window, was given IV Fibrinolytic therapy. Within three hours, she developed left hemiparesis while her neck pain worsened. Repeat CT brain was unremarkable. Neurologic examination at this stage showed she had quadraparesis with left hemi-sensory loss and new development of right sided horner's syndrome. MRI brain was unremarkable, MRI cervical spine showed spindle shaped extradural mass, likely tumoral hematoma, extending from C2-C6 compressing spinal cord with edema. Neurosurgical evaluation prompted urgent cervical decompression with improvement in her motor function. This case highlights usual presentation with a rarest reason mimicking stroke.