We propose a new state of matter in which the pairing interactions carve out a gap within the interior of a large Fermi ball, while the exterior surface remains gapless. This defines a system which contains both a superfluid and a normal Fermi liquid simultaneously, with both gapped and gapless quasiparticle excitations. This state can be realized at weak coupling. We predict that a cold mixture of two species of fermionic atoms with different mass will exhibit this state. For electrons in appropriate solids, it would define a material that is simultaneously superconducting and metallic.Recent developments in ultracold alkali atomic gases [1] have revitalized interest in some basic qualitative questions of quantum many-body theory, because they promise to make a wide variety of conceptually interesting parameter regimes, which might previously have seemed academic or excessively special, experimentally accessible. With this motivation, and stimulated by questions in quantum chromodynamics (QCD) at high density [2, 3, 4], we here revisit the question of fermion pairing between species whose Fermi surfaces do not precisely match. We have found a possibility that seems to be new and certainly is interesting, and which could turn out to be relevant even for conventional solids.The standard Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer (BCS) [5] theory of superconductivity describes pairing between particles of equal and opposite momentum near a common Fermi surface. For classic s-wave superconductors the pairing occurs between electrons of opposite spin. In the presence of a weak magnetic field, and in particular in the case of ferromagnetic order, the Fermi surfaces of the opposite spins will not match, and the Cooper pairing instability, which was enhanced by vanishing energy denominators, will no longer occur at arbitrarily weak coupling. Larkin and Ovchinnikov and independently Fulde and Ferrell [6] showed that in this circumstance it might be favorable to effectively relatively translate the Fermi surfaces, pairing at a non-zero total momentum (LOFF phase).A simpler situation, conceptually, is that pairing occurs between two species whose Fermi surfaces do not match simply because their densities or effective masses differ. This possibility arises in several contexts. (i) In ultracold atom systems, it could occur simply because there are atoms of different elements. (ii) In solids it could occur for electron populations in two different bands. (iii) In QCD it occurs for different species of quarks (up, down, strange). If the mismatch is small and the two species are alternative states of the same particle (such as the spin up and down states of electrons or two hyperfinespin states of cold 40 K or 6 Li atoms as prepared in experiments [7,8,9, 10]), it can be favorable to equalize the Fermi surfaces, absorbing a cost in kinetic energy, and then to pair at zero momentum following BCS. For larger mismatches, LOFF-type ordering can occur. More elaborate forms of position-dependent ordering, with the superfluid gap having standing w...