Static Positioning under Tree Canopy Using Low-Cost GNSS Receivers and Adapted RTKLIB Software

Abstract

The decrease in costs and dimensions of GNSS receivers has enabled their adoption for a very wide range of users. Formerly mediocre positioning performance is benefiting from recent technology advances, namely the adoption of multi-constellation, multi-frequency receivers. In our study, we evaluate signal characteristics and horizontal accuracies achievable with two low-cost receivers—a Google Pixel 5 smartphone and a u-Blox ZED F9P standalone receiver. The considered conditions include open area with nearly optimal signal reception, but also locations with differing amounts of tree canopy. GNSS data were acquired using ten 20 min observations under leaf-on and leaf-off conditions. Post-processing in static mode was conducted using the Demo5 fork of the RTKLIB open source software, which is adapted for usage with lower quality measurement data. The F9P receiver provided consistent results with sub-decimeter median horizontal errors even under tree canopy. The errors for the Pixel 5 smartphone were under 0.5 m under open-sky conditions and around 1.5 m under vegetation canopy. The adaptation of the post-processing software to lower quality data was proven crucial, especially for the smartphone. In terms of signal quality (carrier-to-noise density, multipath), the standalone receiver provided significantly better data than the smartphone.

Raw GNSS data collected using smartphones and low-cost receiver under optimal and sub-optimal conditions

“…The datasets were used as a basis for two studies [5 , 6] focused on applicability of GNSS data from low-cost and smartphone GNSS receivers.…”

Sensors for Digital Transformation in Smart Forestry

“…Localization is of key importance in forestry and other unstructured environments, as the signal transmittance can be obstructed massively-usually one can expect positional accuracy within approximately 5 m of a true position in open sky settings, 7 m in young forest conditions, and 10 m under closed canopies [25]; recent results show better accuracy-this is theoretical up to 1.5 m [26]; however, it is highly dependent on the density of the forest and often there is no signal at all. Therefore, GNSS is rarely used alone but linked to technologies like LiDAR (explained later) to obtain the best location in such unstructured environments [27].…”

Global Navigation Satellite Systems as State-of-the-Art Solutions in Precision Agriculture: A Review of Studies Indexed in the Web of Science

“…This integration leverages the strengths of each system, improves positioning accuracy, and enhances the availability of satellite signals, especially in environments where signal blockages are common, including dense vegetation and other physical structures [42]. In terms of signal processing, the latest developments in multi-constellation receivers focus on advanced algorithms that optimize the utilization of signals from multiple constellations [43]. By combining signals from multiple constellations, the receivers can mitigate the effects of signal blockages, multipath interference, and ionospheric disturbances [44].…”