Anyons are particles with intermediate quantum statistics whose wavefunction acquires a phase e iθ by particle exchange. Inspired by proposals of simulating anyons using ultracold atoms trapped in optical lattices, we study a two-site anyonic Josephson junction, i.e. anyons confined in a onedimensional double-well potential. We show, analytically and numerically, that many properties of anyonic Josephson junctions, such as Josephson frequency, imbalanced solutions, macroscopic quantum self-trapping, coherence visibility, and condensate fraction, crucially depend on the anyonic angle θ. Our theoretical predictions are a solid benchmark for near future experimental quantum simulations of anyonic matter in double-well potentials.