Status of robotic-assisted surgery among Canadian urology residents

Abstract

Background: Robotic-assisted surgery (RAS) has been rapidlyadopted in urology, especially in the United States. Although lessprevalent in Canada, RAS is a growing and controversial field that has implications for resident training. We report on the status and perception of RAS among Canadian urology residents.Methods: All Canadian urology residents from anglophone programs were contacted by email and asked to participate in anonline survey. Current resident exposure to, and perception of,RAS was assessed.Results: Of the residents contacted (n = 128), 50 (39%) completed the survey. Of the respondents, 52% have been involved in RAS. Those who have not been involved in RAS express lower interest and lesser knowledge of RAS. Ninety-two percent of respondents feel the use of RAS will increase, although only 29% feel this is feasible in Canada. Just 24% and 36% feel RAS to be superior to open and laparoscopic techniques, respectively. Sixty-eight percent of residents in programs with a robot viewed it as detrimental to training, whereas 81% of residents in programs without one viewedits absence to either have no impact, or even be beneficial. Bothgroups expressed a desire for more experience with RAS.Conclusion: The resident experience with respect to RAS is mixed. Overall, residents view RAS as an expanding field with potentially negative impacts on their present training, although they appear to desire the acquisition of more experience in RAS. We plan to monitor the evolution of these perceptions over next four years.

The Impact of Training Residents on the Outcome of Robotic-Assisted Sacrocolpopexy

“…Robotic surgery credentials are now required in certain places and in the near future it will be required more widely [9]. The training of residents and fellows on the technique of RASCP is important in both urology [10] and gynecology [11]. Balancing education and patient care is central in any surgery, and careful attention to primum non nocere is essential [12].…”