Staying in the Loop: Formal Feedback Mechanisms Connecting Vocational Training to the World of Work in Europe

Abstract

Context: Vocational education and training (VET) is expected to be designed for creating learning outcomes which meet the needs for skills and competences in the labour market. Hence, identifying current and upcoming skill requirements and ensuring that these requirements are incorporated into education has long been the subject of academic and policy discussion. Governance processes keeping VET systems up-to-date have been more recently addressed as 'feedback mechanisms'. The term broadly summarizes the interplay of institutions, actors and processes which allows the continuous renewal of VET provision (i.e. by creating new qualifications or updating curricula). The aim of the paper is to enhance the understanding of cross-national variations in formally institutionalised 'feedback mechanisms' between VET and the labour market.Method: The research builds on a comparative analysis of case studies in 15 European countries. The paper presents examples for four different 'formal feedback mechanisms' in Germany, France, England, and Austria.Results: Four main types of formal mechanism have been identified: 1) The liberal model explained by VET in England and Higher VET in Austria; 2) The statist model explained by school-based VET in Austria; 3) the participatory model explained by VET in France and 4) the coordinated model explained by apprenticeship training in Germany and Austria.Conclusions: Existing approaches in the economic sociology of labour markets, the varieties of capitalism approach as well as comparative research on welfare states are useful * Corresponding author: markowitsch@3s.co.at ISSN: 2197-8646 http://www.ijrvet.net 286 Markowitsch, Hefler in predicting whether particular VET systems are likely to be predominant. However, they do not provide an alternative in describing differences in VET systems which the concept of formal feedback mechanism does. Moreover, by analysing formal feedback mechanisms, it is possible to demarcate where a VET sub-system ends and another VET sub-systems begins. In this sense research presented here also asks for new standards for comparative VET research as it suggests that entities to be compared are not countries' overall VET systems, but their potential sub-systems.

Skills for Future Work (H2030): Multigroup Analysis in Professional and Baccalaureate Training

“…This is tightly linked with the working world and favors professional incorporation (Rivera, 2016). All of the above could favor a more integrated vision of the different disciplines making up the working ambit, placing emphasis on the multidisciplinary component for students (Breit & Preckel, 2020; Markowitsch & Hefler, 2018).…”

“…These are usually decided upon for political and general reasons, rather than being designed to measure for students or according to an interactional model of aforementioned skills so that they can be developed synergistically and consistently. This is important so that skills are joined up and work effectively toward the aim of promoting adolescent inclusion in the workforce and in lifelong learning (Markowitsch & Hefler, 2018).…”

“…However, such change has increasingly been characterized by occasional moves toward more complementary aspects of the system to the detriment of more substantial changes demanding new structures or a more updated pedagogical model. Within these aforementioned complementary elements, the use of new resources, social skill development, or implementation of new digital communication tools can be highlighted (Expósito et al, 2019; Markowitsch & Hefler, 2018).…”

Perceptions of Workplace, Principal, and Productive Teachers on Students’ Work Readiness in SMK Negeri 5 Surabaya Indonesia

“…Students' experiences during internship (what students have experienced) is very important to note how their experiences (how they learn from those experiences when involved in work and what they learned) serve as a preparation of work readiness in the future [14].…”

Vocational Business Students’ Conceptions and Misconceptions of Taxes as an Input for Instruction and Curriculum Development

“…The target group of this study are students from the fourth grade of business colleges in Austria. Business colleges in Austria can be described as five-year full-time upper secondary schools which lead to a university entry qualification and provide a business-related vocational education (Markowitsch & Hefler, 2018). One focus of the curriculum is entrepreneurship education.…”