Distinctly different: Two 1‐oxa‐2‐silacyclopentenes and a saturated congener have been synthesized and demonstrated to provide access to type II anion relay chemistry (ARC) through a fundamentally new mechanistic pathway. Similar to previous studies, but contrary to initial hypothesis, Brook rearrangement additives (hexamethylphosphoramide and CuI) are necessary to promote Si migration and anion capture.