Conspectus
Biological systems have often served as inspiration
for the design
of synthetic catalysts. The lock and key analogy put forward by Emil
Fischer in 1894 to explain the high substrate specificity of enzymes
has been used as a general guiding principle aimed at enhancing the
selectivity of chemical processes by optimizing attractive and repulsive
interactions in molecular recognition events. However, although a
perfect fit of a substrate to a catalytic site may enhance the selectivity
of a specific catalytic reaction, it inevitably leads to a narrow
substrate scope, excluding substrates with different sizes and shapes
from efficient binding. An ideal catalyst should instead be able to
accommodate a wide range of substrates—it has indeed been recognized
that enzymes also are often highly promiscuous as a result of their
ability to change their conformation and shape in response to a substrate—and
preferentially be useful in various types of processes. In biological
adaptation, the process by which species become fitted to new environments
is crucial for their ability to cope with changing environmental conditions.
With this in mind, we have been exploring catalytic systems that can
adapt their size and shape to the environment with the goal of developing
synthetic catalysts with wide scope.
In this Account, we describe
our studies aimed at elucidating how
metal catalysts with flexible structural units adapt their binding
pockets to the reacting substrate. Throughout our studies, ligands
equipped with tropos biaryl units have been explored, and the palladium-catalyzed
allylic alkylation reaction has been used as a suitable probe to study
the adaptability of the catalytic systems. The conformations of catalytically
active metal complexes under different conditions have been studied
by both experimental and theoretical methods. By the design of ligands
incorporating two flexible units, the symmetry properties of metal
complexes could be used to facilitate conformational analysis and
thereby provide valuable insight into the structures of complexes
involved in the catalytic cycle. The importance of flexibility was
convincingly demonstrated when a phosphine group in a privileged ligand
that is well-known for its versatility in a number of processes was
exchanged for a tropos biaryl phosphite unit: the result was a truly
self-adaptive ligand with dramatically increased scope.