Modulating the diastereoselectivity of stereochemically complex molecules in asymmetric synthesis remains a challenge, especially when the reaction cycle produces no net change in the catalysts, ligands, substrates or additives. Here we accomplish a controlled diastereodivergence in the asymmetric synthesis of fully functionalized tetrahydropyrans by adjusting the sequence of an organocatalytic cascade reaction. We also show that this one-pot operation provides two synthetically important architectures with excellent stereocontrol. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first published kinetic resolution of MBH alcohols in an organocascade.