The synthesis of optically active b-benzyl-g-butyrolactones from butynediol via four transition metal catalysed reactions is reported. Key reactions are the hitherto unknown enantioselective hydrogenation of 2-benzyl-2-buten-1,4-diols using Ir(I)-phosphinooxazoline catalysts and the regiocontrolled oxidation of the resulting 2-benzyl-1,4-butanediols to the b-substituted butyrolactones.Key words: (+)-b-benzyl g-butyrolactones, butynediol, enantioselective hydrogenation Butyrolactone lignans 1 3 are an important class of natural products possessing notable biological activities, in particular antiviral, 4 cytotoxic 5 and canceroprotective 6 properties. We have recently reported a short synthesis of racemic butyrolactone lignans 1 via a-alkylation of b-substituted butyrolactones 2 (Scheme 1). 7 These lactone intermediates were prepared by Raney-Nickel or Pd/C catalysed hydrogenation of the corresponding unsaturated lactones 3, which were obtained from butynediol 4 in three transition metal catalysed reactions. 7
Scheme 1 Retrosynthesis of lactone lignans 1Since natural lignans 1 are generally non-racemic, an asymmetric hydrogenation of 3a-d to 2a-d using chiral catalysts was envisioned to provide optically active lignans and analogs (Scheme 2). Transition metal catalysed asymmetric hydrogenation of b-or g-methylene butyrolactones have been described. 8 However, we observed that butenolides 3a-d gave poor conversions upon homogeneous hydrogenation in the presence of chiral catalysts (Table 1). Thus, butenolides 3a,b were converted to lactones 2a,b in about 20% and 12% ee (2 h, 100 bar H 2 ) using Ir(I)-phosphinooxazoline catalyst A 9 (Table 1, entries 1 and 3). The conversion was 58% after 18 hours while the ee remaining low at 12% (entry 2). Similarly, reduction of 3b or 3d in presence of R-(+)-BINAP-Ru(II) 10 (120 h, 20-30 bar) afforded lactones 2b and 2d in 55 and 95% conversion, again with low ee (entries 4 and 5). 11It was reported that yeast reduction of butenolides afforded the corresponding lactones with good ee. 12 In our case, substrate 3c was reduced by yeast in the presence 12 or in the absence 13 of saccharose. The conversion of 3c to lactone 2c was 20% in each instance and the product was obtained as a racemic mixture (entries 6 and 7).
Scheme 2 Attempted enantioselective reductions of lactones 3a-dSince neither asymmetric hydrogenation nor yeast reduction gave lactones 2 in acceptable yields and enantioselectivities, a different synthetic strategy was necessary. Thus, lactones 2 should be obtained by regioselective TPAP oxidation of optically active diols 5, prepared by asymmetric hydrogenation of butenediols 6 (Scheme 3).Scheme 3 New strategy for the preparation of optically active lactones 2