Stereotypes among health professions in Indonesia: an explorative study

Abstract

Purpose: Effective and efficient health services require efforts to increase collaboration among health professionals. One of the barriers to effective collaboration is stereotypes. Stereotypes represent perceptions or perspectives about a person or group of people. This study aims to explore the perceptions of health professional students and practitioners regarding stereotypes. Methods: This was a qualitative study using a phenomenology approach. A sample of health professions students from both preclinical and clinical stages, as well as health practitioners, was selected using a maximum variation sampling method. Primary data collection was conducted through focus group discussions. Data obtained were analyzed using thematic analysis. A total of nine focus group discussions were conducted. Results: Four themes were identified from this study, including the types of stereotypes, factors affecting stereotype formation, the implications of stereotypes, and how to overcome stereotypes. Stereotype formation was affected by the lack of understanding of other health professions' roles, hierarchical culture, personal experience in receiving healthcare, and community view. Stereotypes among health professionals created obstacles to healthcare team communication and reduced self-confidence in certain health professionals. These stereotypes may be overcome through competency development and knowledge sharing among professionals as well as through education on other health care professionals' roles and competencies so that each profession possessed similar goals for patient safety. Conclusion: Both positive and negative stereotypes negatively affected collaboration. Stereotypes were greatly affected by multifactorial causes. Therefore, understanding other professions' roles and conducting interprofessional education are important to overcome stereotypes.

Could Perception of Digital Learning Environment Potentially Affect First-Year Undergraduate Medical Students Learning Motivation? A Study during Distance Learning Transition due to the COVID-19 Pandemic in Indonesia

“…Therefore, it fostered self-confidence in students. Students with high academic perceptions might have managed to make arrangements in terms of independent learning abilities because they believe they can do a job successfully, which can then be referred into a form of motivation (39)(40)(41)(42).…”

Can I work with older workers if I hold stereotypes regarding their competence? The consequences for stereotype holders.

“…Additionally, the literature suggests that incompetence stereotypes may impact the effectiveness of work interactions. For example, Darmayani et al (2020) interviewed 71 health professionals on the implications of stereotypes on effective collaboration and the quality of care. Findings suggested that incompetence stereotypes may inhibit communication between team members.…”

“…Findings suggested that incompetence stereotypes may inhibit communication between team members. In fact, participants perceived stereotypes as a barrier to effective collaboration in the workplace (Darmayani et al, 2020). Furthermore, findings from an experimental study in business situations showed that perceptions of competence acted as an indicator of the negotiator’s ability to provide instrumental support and significantly affected participants’ decision to collaborate with the negotiator (Zhang et al, 2021).…”

Evaluasi Persepsi dan Kompetensi Pendidikan Interprofesional Mahasiswa di Rotasi Klinik

“…6 Faktor yang dapat menghambat komunikasi dan kinerja tim interprofesi adalah persepsi negatif terhadap profesi lain. 7 Persepsi meliputi kegiatan penerimaan, pengorganisasian, dan proses interpretasi terhadap stimulus. Persepsi mengenai IPE berhubungan dengan segala asumsi seseorang terhadap IPE yang mempengaruhi sikap dan perilaku seseorang terhadap IPE.…”