Stochastic Actuarial Modelling of a Defined-Benefit Social Security Pension Scheme: An Analytical Approach

Abstract

Among the systems in place in different countries for the protection of the population against the long-term contingencies of old-age (or retirement), disability and death (or survivorship), defined-benefit social security pension schemes, i.e. social insurance pension schemes, by far predominate, despite the recent trend towards defined-contribution arrangements in social security reforms. Actuarial valuations of these schemes, unlike other branches of insurance, continue to be carried out almost exclusively on traditional, deterministic lines. Stochastic applications in this area, which have been restricted mainly to occasional special studies, have relied on the simulation technique. This paper develops an analytical model for the stochastic actuarial valuation of a social insurance pension scheme. Formulae are developed for the expected values, variances and covariances of and among the benefit expenditure and salary bill projections and their discounted values, allowing for stochastic variation in three key input factors, i.e., mortality, new entrant intake, and interest (net of salary escalation). Each deterministic output of the valuation is thus supplemented with a confidence interval, that is, a range with an attached probability. The treatment covers the premiums under the different possible financial systems for these schemes, which differ from the funding methods of private pensions, as well as the testing of the level of the Fund ratio when the future contributions schedule is pre-determined. Although it is based on a relatively simplified approach and refers only to retirement pensions, with full adjustment in line with salary escalation, the paper brings out the stochastic features of pension scheme projections and illustrates a comprehensive stochastic valuation. It is hoped that the paper will stimulate interest in further research, both of a theoretical and a practical nature, and lead to progressively increasing recourse to stochastic methods in social insurance pension scheme valuations.

A “Swedish” actuarial balance for a notional defined contribution pension scheme with disability and minimum pension benefits

“…Interested readers can consult Plamondon et al (2002), Boado-Penas, Valdés-Prieto and Vidal-Meliá (2008); Boado-Penas and Vidal-Meliá (2012), Billig and Ménard (2013) and Ventura-Marco and Vidal-Meliá (2014) for an in-depth study of the main differences and similarities. For a stochastic perspective, see Iyer (2008Iyer ( , 2015. 7.…”

A Stochastic Markov Chain for Estimating New Entrants into Professional Pension Funds

“…A common assumption following Dufresne (1988) is that the population of active members is stationary, such that every contributor who retires is replaced by a new individual. Bowers et al (1986) support a closer integration between the stochastic and deterministic approaches, also in relation to new entrants which they model through population dynamics with stochastic rates of change (see also Iyer 2008Iyer , 2015. Lee (1993), Lee and Tuljapurkar (1994) and Rosati (1996) propose stochastic fertility models that can be used to assess future workers and, consequently, new contributors to national pension schemes.…”

Sustainability and inequality of Taiwan's National Pension Insurance

“…To assess whether the NPI generates inequality, we calculate fair rates to measure pension benefits and welfare for various NPI members. The fair rate is the general average premium (GAP) as proposed by Iyer (1999Iyer ( , 2008 and Plamondon et al (2004). Our fair rate is also the constant contribution rate (CCR) used by Plamondon et al (2004) to measure the full funding of a pension scheme, which balances premium revenues and benefit payments.…”