Stochastic and deterministic multiscale models for systems biology: an auxin-transport case study

Abstract

BackgroundStochastic and asymptotic methods are powerful tools in developing multiscale systems biology models; however, little has been done in this context to compare the efficacy of these methods. The majority of current systems biology modelling research, including that of auxin transport, uses numerical simulations to study the behaviour of large systems of deterministic ordinary differential equations, with little consideration of alternative modelling frameworks.ResultsIn this case study, we solve an auxin-transport model using analytical methods, deterministic numerical simulations and stochastic numerical simulations. Although the three approaches in general predict the same behaviour, the approaches provide different information that we use to gain distinct insights into the modelled biological system. We show in particular that the analytical approach readily provides straightforward mathematical expressions for the concentrations and transport speeds, while the stochastic simulations naturally provide information on the variability of the system.ConclusionsOur study provides a constructive comparison which highlights the advantages and disadvantages of each of the considered modelling approaches. This will prove helpful to researchers when weighing up which modelling approach to select. In addition, the paper goes some way to bridging the gap between these approaches, which in the future we hope will lead to integrative hybrid models.

Evolutionary symbolic discovery for bioinformatics, systems and synthetic biology

“…Thus sibling disciplines systems [2,27] and synthetic [7] biology depend crucially on the availability of sophisticated and expressive modeling methodologies and tools. Infobiotics approaches [40,25], also called Executable biology [14] and Algorithmic Systems Biology [35] are gaining momentum as alternative ways of modeling large biological complex systems. Infobiotics is based on models that are built not by specifying differential equations but rather mechanistically by defining algorithms (under a variety of possible formalisms) whose execution mimics the causal relation behind change and time/space dynamics in biological systems.…”

Modelado predictivo de la epidemia de Chikungunya

“…Entre ellos podemos mencionar los continuos-deterministas (Twycross et al, 2010), y aquellos discretos-estocásticos (Mura, 2010). En el contexto de este trabajo de investigación, nos limitamos a considerar el enfoque continuo-determinista, el más utilizado a la hora de construir modelos matemáticos en epidemiología.…”

Multiscale modelling of auxin transport in the plant-root elongation zone

“…The derived equations provide insight into the underlying dynamics and show how the cell-scale parameters influence the effective velocity and diffusivity of the auxin flux. The benefits of this multiscale analytical approach have recently been highlighted by Twycross et al (2010). Similar modelling approaches have been used to study calcium dynamics (Goel et al 2006), pattern formation (Newell et al 2008) and nutrient distributions (Shipley et al 2009), for example, and the effective tissue-scale auxin transport has also been considered in Chavarría-Krauser and Ptashnyk (2009); Kramer (2002); Martin et al (1990); Mitchison (1980a,b); Mitchison et al (1981) and Newell et al (2008).…”