Let S = {x 2 + c 1 , x 2 + c 2 , . . . , x 2 + c s } be a set of quadratic polynomials with rational coefficients, and let P be a rational basepoint. We classify the pairs (S, P ) for which P has finite orbit for S, assuming that the maximum period length for each individual polynomial is at most three (conjectured by Poonen). In particular, under these hypotheses we prove that if s ≥ 4, then there are no points P with finite orbit for S. Moreover, we use this perspective to formulate an analog of the Morton-Silverman Conjecture for sets of rational functions.