Stopping‐power ratio estimation for proton radiotherapy using dual‐energy computed tomography and prior‐image constrained denoising

Abstract

Background: Dual-energy computed tomography (DECT) is a promising technique for estimating stopping-power ratio (SPR) for proton therapy planning. It is known, however, that deriving electron density (ED) and effective atomic number (EAN) from DECT data can cause noise amplification in the resulting SPR images. This can negate the benefits of DECT. Purpose: This work introduces a new algorithm for estimating SPR from DECT with noise suppression, using a pair of CT scans with spectral separation. The method is demonstrated using phantom measurements. Materials and methods: An iterative algorithm is presented, reconstructing ED and EAN with noise suppression, based on Prior Image Constrained Denoising (PIC-D). The algorithm is tested using a Siemens Definition AS+ CT scanner (Siemens Healthcare, Forchheim, Germany). Three phantoms are investigated: a calibration phantom (CIRS 062M), a QA phantom (CATPHAN 700), and an anthropomorphic head phantom (CIRS 731-HN). A task-transfer function (TTF) and the noise power spectrum are derived from SPR images of the QA phantom for the evaluation of image quality. Comparisons of accuracy and noise for ED, EAN, and SPR are made for various versions of the algorithm in comparison to a solution based on Siemens syngo.via Rho/Z software and the current clinical standard of a single-energy CT stoichiometric calibration. A gamma analysis is also applied to the SPR images of the head phantom and water-equivalent distance (WED) is evaluated in a treatment planning system for a proton treatment field. Results:The algorithm is effective at suppressing noise in both ED and EAN and hence also SPR. The noise is tunable to a level equivalent to or lower than that of the syngo.via Rho/Z software. The spatial resolution (10% and 50% frequencies in the TTF) does not degrade even for the highest noise suppression investigated, although the average spatial frequency of noise does decrease. The PIC-D algorithm showed better accuracy than syngo.via Rho/Z for low density materials. In the calibration phantom, it was superior even when excluding lung substitutes, with root-mean-square deviations for ED and EAN less than 0.3% and 2%, respectively, compared to 0.5% and 3%. In the head phantom, however, the SPR accuracy of the PIC-D algorithm was comparable (excluding sinus tissue) to that derived from syngo.via Rho/Z: less than 1% error for soft tissue, brain, and trabecular bone substitutes and 5-7% for cortical bone, withThis is an open access article under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

The influence of dual-energy computed tomography image noise in proton therapy treatment planning

“…Instead, the approach described by Zimmerman et al was used to create a look-up table from to ( Fig. S3 ) [28] . For a more comprehensive description and analysis of this approach, see Section S3.…”

Algorithm for Using Dual Energy Computed Tomography to Determine Chemical Composition: A Feasibility Study

“…[ [25][26][27]. The algorithm proposed in this study currently conducts image evaluation on substances consisting of three to six components, but it is necessary to decompose substances based on information on CT volume to be applied to clinical situations.…”