Strangers in a strange land: Globally unusual thermal tolerance in Collembola from the Cape Floristic Region

Abstract

Specific trait–environment interactions have led to globally unusual botanical radiations in the Cape Floristic Region (CFR) of South Africa. Yet it is unclear whether such interactions have similarly resulted in the diversification of the fauna independently of associations with plants. We explore this question for the Collembola genus Seira, which includes 89 species in the CFR, and appears to have diversified substantially into warm, dry fynbos shrublands—habitats atypical of those usually occupied by Collembola. Specifically, we determine whether thermal tolerance is higher for members of the genus in these shrublands compared with congeners in cooler, moister Afrotemperate Forests in the region, and with Collembola globally. Fynbos‐inhabiting Seira species have remarkable critical thermal maxima (CTmax) of on average 43°C, 5–6°C higher than congeners occupying the Southern Afrotemperate Forests, and Collembola globally, even when taking CTmax variation associated with regional climate into consideration. Thermal tolerance trait variation among the Seira species from different habitats is likely the consequence of variation in habitat temperature: fynbos shrublands are on average ~17°C warmer than Afrotemperate Forests. Moreover, periodic fires in the fynbos have a large effect on microhabitat temperatures, increasing them substantially (by ~7.5°C) in the year after fire, which may be especially relevant in selecting for higher thermal tolerance in species from this habitat. These results suggest that the remarkable richness of Seira in the CFR may in part be due to the evolution of very high CTmax values which have enabled them to take advantage of a hot, dry habitat that is unusual for Collembola. A free Plain Language Summary can be found within the Supporting Information of this article.

Realised rather than fundamental thermal niches predict site occupancy: Implications for climate change forecasting

“…As all sites comprised shrubland or semi-desert environments with sparse vegetation, which have thermal landscapes that are relatively homogenous when compared to more complex forest environments, and the ant species studied were all epigaeic, this soil temperature measurement was determined to be characteristic of the site as a whole. We do, however, acknowledge that although this approach affords complete temporal coverage, which captures the largest variance in thermal environment for the study sites (Liu et al, 2020…”

Alternative biome states challenge the modelling of species' niche shifts under climate change

“…And this distinction is not exclusive for large vertebrates that dominate open habitats (Bond, 2019). For instance, the most important factor determining the assembly of ant species in Australia is whether they live in an open or closed biome (Andersen, 2019); and South African forests and shrublands also differ in the assembly of Collembola, with contrasted functional traits in each biome (Liu et al., 2020). Open/closed environments have also generated species divergences in animals, including elephants (Rohland et al., 2010), birds (Slabbekoorn & Smith, 2002) and even hominids (Roberts et al., 2016).…”

Interactions between developmental and adult acclimation have distinct consequences for heat tolerance and heat stress recovery

“…heathardening) and long-term developmental and adult acclimation responses to the phenotypic plasticity of thermal limits has proven a complex task in ectotherms. Because thermal tolerance correlates strongly with geographic distribution and population abundance or viability in insects (Sørensen et al, 2005a,b;Mitchell et al, 2011;Kellermann et al, 2012;Vorhees et al, 2013;Overgaard et al, 2014;Andersen et al, 2015;Bush et al, 2016;Liu et al, 2020), modeling the contribution of different forms of acclimation to thermal plasticity might prove pivotal in our ability to predict species' responses to climate change (Allen et al, 2016;Sinclair et al, 2016;González-Tokman et al, 2020;Braschler et al, 2020).…”