“…As in the present paper, Liu and Serfes (2004) have found that moving from no discrimination (no information) to discrimination is bad for industry profits and good for consumer surplus. However, conditional on the availability of information, they have 14 For other recent papers on BBPD and customer recognition, see also Caillaud and De Nijs (2011), Chen and Pearcy (2010), Esteves (2010), Esteves and Vasconcelos (2014), Esteves and Reggiani (2014), Gehrig et al (2011Gehrig et al ( , 2012, Ghose and Huang (2009), Ouksel and Eruysal (2011, 2013. 15 They define targetability as a firm's ability to predict the preferences and purchase behaviors of individual consumers.…”