Strategies for Overcoming Site and Recruitment Challenges in Research Studies Based in Intensive Care Units

Abstract

Although enrolling a sufficient number of participants is a challenge for any multisite clinical trial, recruiting patients who are critically ill and receiving mechanical ventilatory support presents additional challenges because of the severity of the patients’ illness and the impediments to their communication. Recruitment challenges related to the research sites, nursing staff, and research participants faced in the first 2 years of a 4-year multisite clinical trial of a patient-directed music intervention for managing anxiety in the intensive care unit were determined. Strategies to overcome these challenges, and thereby increase enrollment, were devised. Individual strategies, such as timing of screening on a unit, were tailored to each participating site to enhance recruitment for this trial. Other strategies, such as obtaining a waiver for a participant’s signature, were instituted across all participating sites. Through implementation of these various strategies, the mean monthly enrollment of participants increased by 50%. Investigators are advised to plan well in advance of starting recruitment for a clinical trial based in an intensive care unit, anticipate peaks and valleys in recruitment, and be proactive in addressing issues creatively as the issues arise.

Effect of continuous oral suctioning on the development of ventilator-associated pneumonia: A pilot randomized controlled trial

“…First, recruiting participants who are receiving mechanical ventilatory support for clinical study poses particular challenges (Chlan et al, 2009). Our results are limited by the small size of our sample.…”

Nurse Research Experiences and Attitudes Toward the Conduct of Intensive Care Research

“…However, ICU research is challenging for many reasons, including high patient acuity, the time-sensitive nature of certain interventions, protocol complexity, the lack of decisional capacity of most critically ill patients, and limited research funding. With these points in mind, the successful conduct of ICU research is dependent on collaborative contributions of clinicians and researchers in consultation with substitute decision makers and, when possible, patients (3,4).…”

Rates and determinants of informed consent: A case study of an international thromboprophylaxis trial

“…Centers participating in the pilot phase were those self-referred by committed local investigators or selected for participation based upon prior preparatory work or prior trial successes and existing research infrastructure, including the presence of experienced research coordinators [34]. Between years 1 and 4 of the full trial, consent rates increased each year, in keeping with growing familiarity of the research and clinical staff with trial communication.…”