Strengthening breast cancer services in Vietnam: a mixed-methods study

Abstract

BackgroundIncidence of breast cancer has increased in Vietnam over the past two decades, but little data exists to inform policy and planning. This study examined the organisation and delivery of breast cancer services in Vietnam in order to address the lack of data on detection, diagnosis and treatment.MethodsWe gathered quantitative and qualitative data using an adapted survey-based Service Availability and Readiness Assessment (SARA) tool and semi-structured interviews from healthcare providers in 69 healthcare facilities about the experience and challenges of delivering breast cancer services. We conducted our study across four levels of the health system in three provinces in Vietnam.ResultsThe analysis of our data show that a number of areas require strengthening particularly in relation to service availability and service readiness. Firstly, healthcare providers across all levels of the health system reported that service provision was constrained by a lack of resources both in relation to health infrastructure and training for healthcare providers. Secondly, access to timely diagnosis and treatment is limited due to services only being available at the top two levels of the health system. Women living outside the immediate vicinity of such facilities tend to find access more costly and time-consuming, and there is a need to investigate the social, economic, geographic and cultural barriers that may prevent women from accessing services.ConclusionsOur study suggests that there is a need to strengthen lower levels of the Vietnamese health system in relation to the detection of breast cancer. Provision of some services such as clinical breast examination, advice on self-examination, and conducting ultrasound tests (supported with appropriate training and capacity-building of healthcare providers) at commune and district levels of the health system may reduce the overcrowding and service-delivery burden experienced in provincial and national-level hospitals. Empowering lower levels of the health system to conduct breast cancer screening, which is currently undertaken on an ad hoc basis through higher-level facilities, is likely to improve access to services for women.

Factors associated with breast cancer awareness and breast self-examination in Fiji and Kashmir India – a cross-sectional study

“…Hence, it is important to consider this issue when planning temporary or permanent programs to promote BCA. However, this might be a difficult challenge [ 30 ].…”

Situational analysis of breast health care systems: Why context matters

“…As of January 2020, a total of 5 BHGI assessments have been performed in Tanzania, Brazil, Uganda, Panama, and India (Table 3). 39‐47 Assessment reports have included analysis of the questionnaire data as well as data regarding breast cancer mortality and incidence rates (when available), stage distribution from national and regional facilities, and exisiting peer‐reviewed literature concerning breast cancer epidemiology in the country or region. A review of governmental policies, state and private insurance rates versus out‐of‐pocket payments for services, workforce shortages, and health system organization also is included.…”

Experiences of accessing and using breast cancer services in Vietnam: a descriptive qualitative study

“…Research surveying and interviewing healthcare providers (HCPs) has indicated that there is a need for breast cancer systems strengthening across all levels of the Vietnamese health system and that lower levels of the health system often lack sufficient capacity to detect and diagnose breast cancer 7. The absence of qualitative data on breast cancer services from the perspective of women with a breast cancer diagnosis8 limits the effective planning of breast cancer services.…”