The atomic proximity of two disparate structural motifs in interleaved structures such as that adopted by La2NiO4, which alternates rock salt and perovskite motifs, offers potential synergistic effects and increased tunability for electrocatalyst behavior. Structural and voltammetric analysis of the intersecting composition series LaSrNi1−yFeyO4+δ and La2−xSrxNi0.7Fe0.3O4+δ show that tuning different cation sites uniquely affects structure and behavior. Correlations between X‐ray diffraction and Raman spectroscopy results reveal that structural changes in the a‐b plane are uniformly matched by the c‐axis following La−Sr exchange, while Ni−Fe exchange distorts the structure by expanding the crystal c‐axis and generating oxygen defects with a distinct signature in Raman spectra. Correlations between rotating ring‐disk electrode voltammetry results and structural parameters show that only Fe substitution has a direct effect on the electrocatalytic oxygen reduction reaction. We link systematic changes observed for onset of electrocatalytic oxygen reduction reaction, Tafel slope, and selectivity to distortions in the B‐site environments. This analysis demonstrates that correlational analysis linking electrochemical behavior parameters to multiple structural characterization techniques is an effective means to probe the effect of individual compositional substitution on electrocatalytic behavior.