The St. Petersburg paradox (Bernoulli 1738) concerns the fair entry fee in a game where the winnings are distributed as P (X = 2 k ) = 2 −k , k = 1, 2, . . .. The tails of X are not regularly varying and the sequence S n of accumulated gains has a remarkable asymptotic behavior: as Martin-Löf (1985) and Csörgő and Dodunekova (1991) showed, S n /n − log 2 n has a class of semistable laws as subsequential limit distributions. This has led to a clarification of the paradox and an interesting and unusual asymptotic theory in past decades. In this paper we prove that S n can be approximated by a semistable Lévy process {L(n), n ≥ 1} with a.s. error O( √ n(log n) 1+ε ) and, surprisingly, the error term is asymptotically normal, exhibiting an unexpected central limit theorem in St. Petersburg theory.MSC 2010. 60E07, 60F05, 60F17.