“…For example, carbon fibres (CFs; An et al, 2018 ; Liu et al, 2018a ), activated CF (ACF; Chen et al, 2013 ), and polyvinyl chloride (PVC) plastic ( Xia et al, 2010 ; Liu et al, 2014 ; von Ammon et al, 2018 ) are widely used as carriers for microorganisms due to the advantages of their physicochemical properties (i.e., strong stability, superior biocompatibility, and large specific surface area). Furthermore, the effects of artificial substrates on periphytons have been analysed in several studies and compared to those on natural substrates, focusing on biomass, microbial diversity, and community structure ( Li et al, 2020a ; Mai et al, 2020 ), purification efficiency and the removal mechanisms of periphytons for different contaminants ( Matsumoto et al, 2012 ; Stern et al, 2017 ; An et al, 2018 ), and metabolic functions ( Boisson and Perrodin, 2006 ). Most previous studies only evaluated the bacterial communities developed on artificial substrates or natural substrates ( Besemer, 2015 ; Miao et al, 2019 ; Oberbeckmann and Labrenz, 2020 ).…”