Four Jurassic ophiolite complexes in northern California have crystallization ages of 170-160 Ma; the Coast Range (including Great Valley) ophiolite is oldest (170-165 Ma), the Smartville ophiolite, intermediate (164-160 Ma), and the Josephine ophiolite, youngest (162 Ma). The Smartville ophiolite was obducted during the Sierran phase of the Nevadan orogeny (162-155 Ma), and the Josephine ophiolite was obducted during the Klamath phase of the Nevadan orogeny (153-150 Ma). The Great Valley ophiolite was not highly deformed during the Nevadan orogeny and became oceanic basement for the post-Nevadan forearc basin. Three conflicting models for origin of the Coast Range (including Great Valley) ophiolite have been proposed: (1) Formation by intra-arc and backarc spreading related to an east-facing intraoceanic arc, which collided with a west-facing continental-margin arc during the Nevadan orogeny (Sierran phase).
(2) Formation by openocean seafloor spreading and incorporation into the continental margin during trench initiation outboard of an existing continental-margin trench. (3) Formation by forearc oblique rifting along the continental margin, followed by partial closure.Lithospheric rifting is favored where there is either thick continental crust or thin mantle lithosphere because continental crust is weaker than oceanic crust and both are weaker than mantle lithosphere. Favorable sites for rifting are extant rifts, intra-arc settings, suture belts, and areas where mantle lithosphere has been delaminated from overlying crust. Upon cessation of magmatism related to rifting or subduction, mantle lithosphere rapidly strengthens, so that by 20 m.y., lithosphere strongly resists extensional stresses. Forearcs cool and strengthen even faster because of refrigeration by subducted slabs. Mature forearcs are strong and unlikely to yield to stresses, especially when weaker intra-arc and backarc settings are nearby.
Trench initiation is favored by (1) the presence of a preexisting lithospheric boundary, (2) the presence of thin oceanic lithosphere, (3) attempted subduction of buoyant crust, and (4) plate reorganization. Trench initiation in intact oceaniclithosphere older than 20 m.y. is implausible. The following facts render models for Jurassic trench initiation (model 2) or rifting (model 3) in forearc settings implausible: (1) Subduction began along the California margin in the Triassic, so that forearc lithosphere was considerably older than 20 m.y. by the Late Jurassic. (2) The Triassic-Jurassic magmatic arc related to this earlier subduction zone died in eastern California at the same time that the Jurassic-Cretaceous magmatic arc was initiated in the westernmost Sierra Nevada. (3) The colliding buoyant crust that forced this plate reorganization is found in the Sierran foothills. The most plausible model for formation of the Great Valley, Smartville, and Josephine ophiolites is by lithospheric rifting within and/or behind magmatic arcs. The Great Valley and Smartville ophiolites formed behind an east-facing intraoc...