Sir2 and Hst1 are NAD؉ -dependent deacetylases involved in transcriptional repression in yeast. The two enzymes are highly homologous yet have different sensitivity to the small-molecule inhibitor splitomicin (compound 1) (Bedalov, A., Gatbonton, T., Irvine, W. P., Gottschling, D. E., and Simon, J. A. (2001) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 98, 15113-15118). We have now defined a critical amino acid residue within a small helical module of Hst1 that confers relative resistance to splitomicin. Parallel cell-based screens of 100 splitomicin analogues led to the identification of compounds that exhibit a higher degree of selectivity toward Sir2 or Hst1. A series of compounds based on a splitomicin derivative, dehydrosplitomicin (compound 2), effectively phenocopied a yeast strain that lacked Hst1 deacetylase while having no effect on the silencing activities of Sir2. In addition, we identified a compound with improved selectivity for Sir2. Selectivity was affirmed using whole-genome DNA microarray analysis. This study underscores the power of phenotypic screens in the development and characterization of selective inhibitors of enzyme functions.Sir2-like enzymes constitute a family of NAD ϩ -dependent deacetylases found in diverse organisms ranging from bacteria to humans (1, 2). These highly conserved enzymes catalyze a reaction that requires the consumption of NAD ϩ for the removal of the acetyl group from substrate lysine residues to generate nicotinamide, O-acetyl-ADP-ribose, and lysine (3-10). Initially characterized as histone deacetylases, this family of enzymes was subsequently shown to have a broad range of substrates including p53, BCL6, and ␣-tubulin in mammalian cells and acetyl-CoA synthetase in bacteria (11-17). The yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae has five Sir2-like proteins: Sir2p, Hst1p (homologue of Sir two), Hst2p, Hst3p, and Hst4p (homologues of Sir two) (1, 18). Sir2p and its closest homologue, Hst1p, act as transcriptional repressors by promoting targeted histone deacetylation (11, 19 -21). These two enzymes, however, play distinct cellular roles, since they are directed to different chromatin regions by specificity factors. Sir2p, which is found in two separate multiprotein complexes, is critical for transcriptional silencing of large chromosomal domains at three loci: telomeres, the silent mating-type loci (HMR and HML), and the ribosomal RNA-encoding DNA (reviewed in Ref. 22). Hst1p-mediated repression, in contrast, is restricted to specific genes through the DNA-binding protein Sum1p and the tethering factor Rfm1p (23, 24). Hst1p has previously been known to participate in repression of middle sporulation genes during mitotic growth (23) but has recently been shown to serve as a sensor and a regulator of cellular NAD ϩ levels through controlling the expression of genes involved in de novo NAD ϩ biosynthesis and the import of nicotinic acid (25). Little is known about cellular functions of other NAD ϩ -dependent deacetylases in yeast. Hst2p is a cytoplasmic enzyme that accounts for the majorit...