Adenosine derivatives developed to activate adenosine receptors (ARs) revealed µM activity at serotonin 5HT2B and 5HT2C receptors (5HTRs). We explored the SAR at 5HT2Rs and modeled receptor interactions in order to optimize affinity and simultaneously reduce AR affinity. Depending on N6 substitution, small 5′-alkylamide modification maintained 5HT2BR affinity, which was enhanced upon ribose substitution with rigid bicyclo[3.1.0]hexane (North (N)-methanocarba), e.g. N6-dicyclopropylmethyl 4′-CH2OH derivative 14 (Ki 11 nM). 5′-Methylamide 23 was 170-fold selective as antagonist for 5HT2BR vs. 5HT2CR. 5′-Methyl 25 and ethyl 26 esters potently antagonized 5HT2Rs with moderate selectivity in comparison to ARs; related 6-N,N-dimethylamino analogue 30 was 5HT2R-selective. 5′ position flexibility of substitution was indicated in 5HT2BR docking. Both 5′-ester and 5′-amide derivatives displayed in vivo t1/2 of 3–4 h. Thus, we used GPCR modeling to repurpose nucleoside scaffolds in favor of binding at nonpurine receptors, as novel 5HT2R antagonists, with potential for cardioprotection, liver protection or CNS activity.