“…If one were to insist on such a hard-pomeron singularity, one would thus, to be consistent, also have to argue that NLO perturbative QCD could not be applied in this region. The many quantitative successes of NLO perturbative QCD at HERA [4,24,25] would then have to be considered merely fortuitous. Conversely, if one instead accepts that the success of the perturbative predictions is significant, one would then have to conclude that the simple assumption (3) that the rightmost singularity in the j -plane is a simple pole is incorrect, since the perturbative results rely for their success on a soft input.…”