Student perceptions of online and in-person microbiology laboratory experiences in undergraduate medical education

Abstract

Background: Universities are facing increased budget constraints, often resulting in reduced funds to support microbiology laboratories. Online mock laboratory activities are often instituted as a cost-effective alternative to traditional wet labs for medical students. Objective: The purpose of this study was to examine students' perceptions of online and inperson microbiology lab learning experiences. Design: We investigated undergraduate medical student perception of the in-person and online microbiology lab experience; 164 first-year medical students participated in newly designed online labs, while 83 second-year medical students continued to use in-person labs. An online survey was administered to collect student opinions of the lab experience. Results: In terms of student self-reported learning styles, those students who attended the lab in person were more likely to report a tactile learning style (33% vs 16%) while those students who learned the material online reported a visual learning style preference (77% vs 61%; n = 264). Students felt that the online microbiology lab was more convenient for their schedules when compared to the in-person lab. A greater proportion of online students (12%) felt that they encountered brand-new material on the final quiz than in-person students (1%; n = 245). Even so, 43% of the online educated students and 37% of the in-person educated students perceived their assigned lab experiences to be the optimal lab design, and over 89% of both groups reported a desire for at least some in-person instruction in a wet-laboratory environment. Conclusions: Our findings suggest that, while students are strongly supportive of digital online lab activities, the overwhelming majority of students still report a desire for a blend of online and in-person, hands-on laboratory activities. These findings will further research directed towards student perception of the lab experience and aid in the adaptation of microbiology curriculums to accommodate both student and university needs. ARTICLE HISTORY

Pharmacy Students Perceptions of Their Distance Online Learning Experience During the COVID-19 Pandemic: A Cross-Sectional Survey Study

“…23 While a third study from USA illustrated that the majority of medical students preferred the blinded learning methods consisting of both online and in-person laboratory practice for their microbiology laboratory course. 24 The current study revealed that most students reported that they do not need a computer skill literacy courses and they can use the online learning platforms for communicating effectively with instructors and other students without difficulties. Among the challenges that the participant of the current study students agreed on were lack of the motivation, feeling board during an online class, and that some of them took them long time to adapt to online learning tools.…”

“… 23 While a third study from USA illustrated that the majority of medical students preferred the blinded learning methods consisting of both online and in-person laboratory practice for their microbiology laboratory course. 24 …”

International Students’ Perception of Teaching Microbiology, Virology and Immunology at Medical Universities in Ukraine

“…Kryzhanovskaya et al (2018) investigated the methodological approaches to delivering lectures on MBVI at medical universities, the features of this course and ways to improve it for international students. Hamorak (2015), Ngamskulrungroj et al (2017), and Brockman et al (2020) presented their experience of teaching MBVI with the use of interactive and distance learning technologies.…”

Management lessons through an interactive online discussion about hospital management during the COVID-19 pandemic

“…We chose a format of a virtual moderated podium discussion with questions from the audience. An in-person format was evaluated positively in the past and seemed suitable for our learning objectives [ 8 ], [ 9 ], [ 10 ]. We sought to use this successful in-person format for an online event.…”