Student Perceptions of Team-based Learning vs Traditional Lecture-based Learning

Abstract

Objective. To evaluate pharmacy student perceptions of team-based learning (TBL) vs traditional lecture-based learning formats. Methods. First professional year pharmacy students (N5111) at two universities used TBL in different courses during different semesters (fall vs spring). Students completed a 22-item team perceptions instrument before and after the fall semester. A 14-item teaching style preference instrument was completed at the end of the spring semester. Data were analyzed using Wilcoxon signed rank test and Mann-Whitney U test. Results. Students who experienced TBL in the fall and went back to traditional format in the spring reported improved perceptions of teams and preferred TBL format over a traditional format more than students who experienced a traditional format followed by TBL. Students at both universities agreed that the TBL format assists with critical-thinking, problem-solving, and examination preparation. Students also agreed that teams should consist of individuals with different personalities and learning styles. Conclusion. When building teams, faculty members should consider ways to diversify teams by considering different views, perspectives, and strengths. Offering TBL early in the curriculum prior to traditional lecture-based formats is better received by students, as evidenced by anecdotal reports from students possibly because it allows students time to realize the benefits and assist them in building teamwork-related skills.

Traditional Lectures and Team-Based Learning in an Occupational Therapy Program: A Survey of Student Perceptions

“…In addition, it is suggested that the TBL approach be implemented early in the curriculum so that students realize the possible educational advantages (Frame et al, 2015). Instructors should explain to students both why TBL is being used and the benefits of this approach (Parmelee & Michelson, 2010).…”

Team-Based Learning Experiences of Fourth-Year Pharmacy Students in a South African University

“…During peer evaluation, the team evaluates each member's individual preparation for team work, class attendance, positive contribution to team discussions, and value of their input. 1 Although several publications in the Journal focused on TBL and its outcome in terms of course grades, 9 perception of faculty members, 10 comparison with traditional lecture-based learning, 11 or student performance and perception, 12 no article specifically focused on the learning experiences of students where TBL was the sole method of instruction. This is also the first report on TBL implementation in a South African university's school of pharmacy.…”

Using a Novel Student-centered Teaching Method to Improve Pharmacy Student Learning

“…The Test session as a part of formative assessment in STQD had indirect and direct benefits to students learning, which provided a great boost to knowledge retention after self-study and helped students self-assess and find deficiencies to improve their learning strategies. [36][37][38] Believing in student ability to learn, emphasizing progress toward learning goals rather than score, and assessing the development of learning ability were all manners in which motivation was enhanced through an effective use of formative assessment in STQD. 39 Inductive teaching in STQD could be characterized as a constructivist method, that students constructed their own knowledge rather than had it imparted by the teacher.…”