Students versus locals: Young adults' constructions of the working‐class Other

Abstract

Following a review of the main approaches to the study of class in the social sciences, a critical/discursive approach is adopted to show how analysing an aspect of everyday life such as leisure and 'going out' can reveal the reproduction of dominant discourses about class. Forty-two middle-class young adults were taken on 'nights out' to bars and pubs and then interviewed later to generate group accounts of the people and places they encountered. An analysis of participants' talk about going out to bars and pubs is used to illustrate the ways in which class was constituted in their dialogue. Focusing on the distinction respondents made between students and locals we consider how working-class people are simultaneously rejected and desired and how a discourse of territoriality defines and reproduces class relations in commercial leisure spaces. We argue that social psychology has much to offer contemporary understandings of the ways in which social class is constituted and mobilized in everyday accounts of leisure and consumption, and discuss our analysis in the context of existing research. We end by considering the potential value of our distinctive method for the study of class relations in social psychology research.

Alcohol Consumption, Gender Identities and Women’s Changing Social Positions

“…Discourse analysis is a methodological approach which is now well-established in critical social psychology (Parker 1992;Wetherell et al 2001), having been introduced into Anglo-American psychology in the late 1970s (Willig 2001). It has been usefully applied to many social issues, including the construction of masculine identities (Edley and Wetherell 1997) class identities (Holt and Griffin 2005), asylum seeking and immigration (Capdevila and Callaghan 2008), men's emotion talk (Walton et al 2004), pro-eating disorder websites (Day and Keys 2008); as well as media accounts of women's drinking (Day et al 2004), portrayals of alcohol in women's magazines (Lyons et al 2006), young adults' drinking (Szmigin et al 2008) and teenagers who choose not to drink alcohol (Nairn et al 2006). In broad terms, discourse analysis is concerned with how meanings are produced and reproduced in talk and text (Parker 1994).…”

Class, Students and Place: Encountering Locality in a Post-industrial Landscape

“…The following comments from Daniella show that emotional conflicts and compromises can be experienced by students in less élitist Higher Education settings Daniella may not experience ''the shock of the élite'' (Reay et al, 2009(Reay et al, , p. 1107 at Northtown University but nevertheless for this single parent on benefits embedded in the sub-cultures of the large housing estate (MacDonald et al, 2005), there is a marked difference in the two worlds she encounters and she clearly feels compromised as she moves between the spaces of home and university. Again, this counters the notion that the dynamics and relations of studenthood operate purely in terms of middle-/working-class dichotomies (Holt and Griffin, 2005).…”

‘Not in our front garden’: Land use conflict, spatial meaning and the politics of naming place

“…Some researchers have proposed that a fragmentation of structural narratives has resulted in the decline of the importance of social class (Roberts, 2001). However, the topic of class was often central to participants' spatial understandings (Holt & Griffin, 2005;Skeggs, 2004). Accounts reproduced a number of common assumptions about class; that class relations are dominated by conflict, that social classes do not wish to integrate, and that those lower down the spectrum of social status resent those higher up.…”