“…We have suggested (Dawson and Christman, 1961) that the carbon atoms of positions 1 through 4 of the pyridine ring may arise from an intermediate related to citric acid in a manner such that the carbon of position 3 of citrate becomes the carbon of pyridine ring position 3 of nicotinic acid and subsequently of nicotine. This view is supported by the findings of Griffith et al (1960) and of Byerrum and Griffith (1961) that about 50% of the pyridine ring activity acquired from acetic-2-C14 acid and from /5-alanine-2-C14 is located in ring position 3, and by our observation that about 25% of the pyridine ring activity acquired from /3-alanine-2-C14 is located in ring position 2. If citric acid were converted symmetrically into nicotinic acid (a proximal precursor of the nicotine pyridine ring) by a pathway which avoids the Ogston effect, the remaining 25% of label should occur in ring position 4.…”