Insectivory, growth, and nutrition of Drosera binata var. multifida and D. capensis were studied in long-established plantings in a greenhouse. Exclosures were used to manipulate insect availability to leaves, and substrate phosphorus and nitrogen fertiliser was added to increase these mineral nutrients.Neither species benefitted significantly from insect capture on a nutritional or energetic basis in nutrient-poor or -rich soils. However, both species benefitted from soil nutrient additions, and accumulated Nand P in vegetative organs. Phosphorus levels in shoots were especially high in P fertilised plots for both species. In addition, P concentrations increased significantly in the roots of D. binata. Nitrogen levels in all tissues were slightly higher in N fertilised plots, and statistical differences were observed in roots of D. capensis and in shoots of D. binata. Drosera capensis showed increased growth with Nand P additions, especially in root biomass. However, leaf number and rosette diameter increased where Nand P were added together. This study adds to the growing evidence that insectivory is not as an important nutrient source to insectivorous plants, compared to inorganic soil-acquired nutrients, especially when the soil nutrient concentrations are high.