Catalytic is a crucial reaction for environmental detoxication of pesticides and neutralization of various molecules classified as chemical warfare agents. Herein, we report on a series of tunable Ce‐Zr‐based metal oxides, (ZraCe1‐aOx) prepared using a facile biomineralization technique, as catalysts for organophosphates dephosphorylation. Synchrotron scattering and spectroscopy methods showcase that ZraCe1‐aOx catalysts are highly defective and exhibit an abundance of Ce3+ sites that promote oxygen vacancies needed for enhanced dephosphorylation reactions. The catalytic performance was assessed using a model para‐nitrophenyl phosphate reaction and showcases a strong dependence on Zr dopant concentration and subsequent tuning of the Ce3+/Ce4+ ratio. Analysis of synchrotron datasets allowed structure‐performance correlations between the Ce3+ concentration and associated oxygen vacancies, the dephosphorylation rate constant, and Zr concentration to be established, confirming that Ce3+ as active sites is positively correlated with the rate constant. We envision that similar biomineralization approaches can be used to fabricate Ce3+‐rich Ce‐Zr oxide for environmental application in dephosphorylation and other hydrolysis reactions.