In the present study, the effect of mild to high-temperature regimes on the quasi-static and dynamic tensile behaviours of Barakar sandstone from the Jharia coal mine fire region has been experimentally investigated. The experimental work has been performed on Brazilian disk specimens of Barakar sandstone, which are thermally treated up to 800 °C. The quasi-static and dynamic split tensile strength tests were carried out on a servo-controlled universal testing machine and Split Hopkinson Pressure Bar (SHPB), respectively. Microscopic and mineralogical changes were studied through a petrographic investigation. The experimental results suggest the prevalence of both, static and dynamic loading scenarios after 400 °C. Up to 400 °C, the quasi-static and dynamic tensile strengths increased due to the evaporation of water, which suggests a strengthening effect. However, beyond 400 °C, both strengths decreased significantly as newly formed thermal microcracks became prevalent. The dynamic tensile strength exhibits strain rate sensitivity up to 400 °C, although it shows a marginal decline in this sensitivity beyond this temperature threshold. The Dynamic Increase Factor (DIF) remained constant up to 400 °C and slightly increased after 400 °C. Furthermore, the characteristic strain rate at which the dynamic strength becomes twice the quasi-static strength remains consistent until reaching 400 °C but steadily decreases beyond this temperature. This experimental study represents the first attempt to validate the Kimberley model specifically for thermally treated rocks. Interestingly, the presence of water did not have a significant impact on the failure modes up to 400 °C, as the samples exhibited a dominant tensile failure mode, breaking into two halves with fewer fragments. However, as temperature increased, the failure behaviours became more complex due to the combined influence of thermally induced microcracks and the applied impact load. Cracks initially formed at the centre and subsequently, multiple shear cracks emerged and propagated in the loading direction, resulting in a high degree of fragmentation. This study also demonstrates that shear failure is not solely dependent on the loading rate but can also be influenced by temperature, further affecting the failure mode of the sandstone.