Sublethal metabolic responses to contaminant mixture toxicity in Daphnia magna

Abstract

Anthropogenic activity is increasing the presence of contaminants that enter waterways through wastewater effluent and urban and/or agricultural runoff, generally in complex mixtures. Depending on the mode of action of the individual contaminant within the mixture, toxicity can occur due to contaminants having similar or dissimilar modes of action. However, it is unknown how the metabolome responds to sublethal contaminant mixtures in the keystone genus Daphnia. In the present study we examined D. magna metabolic responses to acute sublethal exposure of propranolol, carbamazepine, and perfluorooctanesulfonic acid (PFOS) as well as in binary (propranolol-carbamazepine, propranolol-PFOS, carbamazepine-PFOS) and tertiary mixtures (carbamazepine-propranolol-PFOS), all at 10% of the median lethal concentration of the population (LC50). The metabolome was measured using H nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) and characterized using principal component analysis, regression analysis, and fold changes in metabolite relative to the unexposed (control) group. The averaged principal component analysis scores plots revealed that carbamazepine-PFOS and carbamazepine-propranolol-PFOS exposures were significantly different from the control treatment. After normalizing the toxicity of each contaminant, we found that some metabolites responded monotonically, whereas others displayed a nonmonotonic response with increasing toxicity units. The single contaminant exposures and 2 binary mixtures (propranolol-carbamazepine, and propranolol-PFOS) resulted in minimal changes in the identified metabolites, whereas the carbamazepine-PFOS and carbamazepine-propranolol-PFOS displayed increases in several amino acid metabolites and decreases in glucose. Overall, our results highlight the sensitivity of the metabolome to distinguish the composition of the contaminant mixtures, with some mixtures displaying heightened responses versus others. Environ Toxicol Chem 2018;37:2448-2457. © 2018 SETAC.

Targeting the Lowest Concentration of a Toxin That Induces a Detectable Metabolic Response in Living Organisms: Time-Resolved In Vivo 2D NMR during a Concentration Ramp

“…Members of the unexposed group were identical with the exception that BPA was not introduced into the NMR flow system. The unexposed control groups (60 Daphnia in total, 20 × 3 replicates) functioned as a reference to which each exposed population was then compared . The trends in the controls versus the exposed trajectories are shown in Figure S3.…”

“…21 This is followed by detection of the LCDR for bisphenol A (BPA), a common plasticizer, 22 which is monitored by amino acid-only 2D NMR. 23 In summary, this paper introduces an experimental framework that can decrease the time needed for in vivo toxicity screening and offers future potential for the study of complex matrices such as contaminant mixtures (to assess synergistic effects 24 ), agricultural runoff, and wastewater.…”

Environmental factors regulate the fatty acid content of primary producers and consumers in a freshwater pond in a warming world

“…Most samples collected for FA were intended to be lyophilized prior to analysis, however, recent advances in NMR spectroscopy (Bastawrous et al 2018) has allowed the analysis of contaminant-induced sub-lethal effects on D. magna metabolites and the potential biochemical processes that may be affected (Kovacevic et al 2018;Wagner et al 2018).…”

Understanding the Fate of Environmental Chemicals Inside Living Organisms: NMR-Based 13C Isotopic Suppression Selects Only the Molecule of Interest within 13C-Enriched Organisms

“…Aquatic organisms are becoming exposed to an ever increasing number and diversity of anthropogenic chemicals that exhibit a range of toxicities. , Furthermore, many chemicals can transform or degrade in the environment, or even within an organism, thus increasing the chance of synergistic toxic effects. , As such, it is important to develop tools that can better evaluate the molecular transformations and sublethal impacts of chemicals in living organisms, which is pivotal for developing optimal environmental policies and practices. , …”

“…1,2 Furthermore, many chemicals can transform or degrade in the environment, or even within an organism, thus increasing the chance of synergistic toxic effects. 3,4 As such, it is important to develop tools that can better evaluate the molecular transformations and sublethal impacts of chemicals in living organisms, 5 which is pivotal for developing optimal environmental policies and practices. 6,7 Conventional aquatic toxicity tests mainly focus on mortality 5 or reproductive success.…”