Submerged discontent and patterns of accommodation: a case study of doctors' pay in two public hospitals in China

Abstract

The article evaluates submerged discontent among Chinese public hospital doctors (Note1) regarding their pay and patterns of accommodation, including doctors' responses through formal and informal actions in the context of health service marketization. On the basis of a case study of two public hospitals, the article illustrates the dynamical impact of marketization on Chinese doctors' pay-related dissatisfaction and health service employment relationship. Because of the authoritarian management and compliant trade unions, the conflict between doctors and hospitals is unable to be accommodated through collective methods. Instead, doctors' discontent is often channelled through informal, individual and subtle activities. Meanwhile, doctors' professional society is gradually influential, showing its potential of developing doctors' group identity and protecting members' interests in future.

Pharmaceutical Sales Representatives in the United States and China: The Need for Professional Public Space

“…In public hospitals, physicians' salaries are mainly determined by hospitals based on their performance assessment (except for a small part set by the government based on their professional titles) [67,4]. Since physicians' professional labor has not been fully valued [126,12], the labor fee for diagnosis and treatment is low, so drug sales 1 have become an important way for physicians and their hospitals to make a profit [4,7,127]. Overprescribing behaviors are encouraged by economic incentives [15,43,71,120,123].…”

Managing under austerity: a qualitative study of management–union relations during attempts to cut labour costs in three South African public hospitals

“…In Iran, industrial action has been prompted by a range of problems (poor training, unclear job boundaries and unpleasant working environments) ( Mahsa et al ., 2023 ). In China, due to authoritarian management and compliant trade unions, conflict can't be managed through collective channels, but is often channelled through informal, individual activities ( Cao, 2014 ). In South Africa, after a series of strikes and the collapse of mediation, a constitutional court ruling decided that a recent multi-year public wage agreement did not need to be upheld as the government had insufficient funds to meet the agreement ( Smit, 2022 ).…”

China’s Physician and Nurse Workforce

“…In 2002, public financing covered only 6-7 percent of hospital spending, while staff wages comprised one-quarter of hospital budgets. 102 Low wages also reflected the concentration of most physicians in salaried positions inside government hospitals. The low salaries paid to physicians have helped to keep hospital operating costs down; labor in Chinese hospitals accounts for only 25-40 percent of operating costs, compared to roughly 50 percent of US hospital operating costs (which do not even include doctor salaries).…”