Pancreatic schwannomas are exceedingly rare tumors arising from Schwann cells of the peripheral nerve sheath within the pancreas. Often asymptomatic or presenting with nonspecific symptoms, these tumors pose a diagnostic challenge due to their mimicry of other pancreatic neoplasms on imaging studies. Histologically, pancreatic schwannomas demonstrate spindle cell proliferation with a distinct Immunohistochemical profile, including positive staining for S-100 protein. Surgical resection remains the cornerstone of treatment, with excellent long-term prognosis following complete excision. Here, we present a case report of a pancreatic schwannoma in a woman presenting with a cystic pancreatic mass, underscoring the importance of considering this rare entity in the differential diagnosis of pancreatic lesions.