Successful yet Precarious: South Asian Muslim Americans, Islamophobia, and the Model Minority Myth

Abstract

Precariousness is the notion that unstable and temporary employment can induce feelings of vulnerability and insecurity. As a “successful” minority because of their high education levels and economic attainments, South Asian Americans can hardly be described as precarious. However, ethnographic observations reveal a collective precariousness felt by this group. Despite measures of success, their positionality as a racialized and stigmatized religious “Other” induces in them an insecurity akin to that felt by those un(der)employed. They fear that despite their achievements, they can be discriminated against in their workplace because of their race and religion. This anxiety influences their education and career choices, and political engagements. Theoretically, precariousness is largely conceptualized as a phenomenon contained within national borders. However, South Asian Muslim Americans’ precariousness is influenced by that of Muslims of other nationalities abroad, underscoring the transnational dimension of precariousness and how it can extend beyond immediate networks and physical borders.

Performing Hybridity or Deflecting Islamophobia? Adaptable Identity Management amongst Young British Pakistani Muslims

“…Both Khadija and Aisha explain how being forced to repress important values and beliefs-in Mir's (2011, p. 554) terms, 'half-disavowal of identity'-can lead to self-recrimination. The exchange above echoes cognate studies (see Mythen 2012;Khan and Mythen 2019;Lems 2021;Shams 2020) and illustrates both the complexities and the accumulative cost of maintaining public equilibrium at the expense of muting cherished facets of culture, faith and identity. External pressure to perform a role that will be acceptable to the majority can be exasperating, as Zahra reflects:…”

Meeting the Moral Markers of Success: Concerted Cultivation among Second‐Generation Muslim Parents*

“…In other words, success was-at least in part-framed as reproducing uppermiddle-class socioeconomic status alongside educational attainment. This finding reflects parents' desire to guard against precariousness in the third generation, a wider fear found to be shared among other Muslim Americans, particularly those of South Asian descent (Shams 2020).…”

Structural Racism and Immigrant Health in the United States

“…Additionally, many immigrant workers do so to provide monetary remittances to countries of origin, which can further constrain resources for health (Acevedo-Garcia et al, 2012), with more hostile policies proposing "double" taxes on these remittances (Ratha et al, 2017). Among immigrant groups with higher levels of success, racialization contributes to ongoing feelings of precariousness and insecurity (Shams, 2020), and challenges remain in terms of equal pay, promotions, and upward mobility (Yi et al, 2016).…”