Bimolecular catalyst
decomposition is a fundamental, long-standing
challenge in olefin metathesis. Emerging ruthenium–cyclic(alkyl)(amino)carbene
(CAAC) catalysts, which enable breakthrough advances in productivity
and general robustness, are now known to be extraordinarily susceptible
to this pathway. The details of the process, however, have hitherto
been obscure. The present study provides the first detailed mechanistic
insights into the steric and electronic factors that govern bimolecular
decomposition. Described is a combined experimental and theoretical
study that probes decomposition of the key active species, RuCl
2
(L)(py)(=CH
2
)
1
(in which L
is the N-heterocyclic carbene (NHC) H
2
IMes, or a CAAC ligand:
the latter vary in the NAr group (NMes, N-2,6-Et
2
C
6
H
3
, or N-2-Me,6-
i
PrC
6
H
3
) and the substituents on the quaternary site
flanking the carbene carbon (i.e., CMe
2
or CMePh)). The
transiently stabilized pyridine adducts
1
were isolated
by cryogenic synthesis of the metallacyclobutanes, addition of pyridine,
and precipitation. All are shown to decompose via second-order kinetics
at −10 °C. The most vulnerable CAAC species, however,
decompose more than 1000-fold faster than the H
2
IMes analogue.
Computational studies reveal that the key factor underlying accelerated
decomposition of the CAAC derivatives is their stronger trans influence,
which weakens the Ru−py bond and increases the transient concentration
of the 14-electron methylidene species, RuCl
2
(L)(=CH
2
)
2
. Fast catalyst initiation, a major design
goal in olefin metathesis, thus has the negative consequence of accelerating
decomposition. Inhibiting bimolecular decomposition offers major opportunities
to transform catalyst productivity and utility, and to realize the
outstanding promise of olefin metathesis.