“…Oddly, a correlation between the carbonate-rich Birmania Formation and the siliciclastic Jodhpur Group has also been suggested recently (Pandey and Bahadur, 2009), although justification for this suggestion was not presented. While recent studies have confirmed that the uppermost siliciclastic units of the Marwar Supergroup are indeed early Cambrian (Kumar and Pandey, 2008;McKenzie et al, 2011a), much of the lower part of the Marwar Supergroup, including the carbonate-rich Bilara Formation, is almost certainly late Neoproterozoic (Kumar, 2012;Mazumdar and Strauss, 2006) Thus, if the Bilara and Birmania formations are directly correlative, the latter is more likely to be Precambrian. Clearly then, the case for a Palaeozoic age for the Birmania Formation based on interpolation alone is weak.…”