Recently, Snider et al (2020 Nature
586 373) reported on the observation of superconductivity in highly compressed carbonaceous sulfur hydride, H
x
(S,C)
y
. The highest critical temperature in H
x
(S,C)
y
exceeds the previous record of T
c = 280 K by 5 K, as reported by Somayazulu et al (2019 Phys. Rev. Lett.
122 027001) for highly compressed LaH10. In this paper, we analyze experimental temperature-dependent magnetoresistance data, R(T,B), reported by Snider et al. The analysis shows that H
x
(S,C)
y
compound exhibited T
c = 190 K (P = 210 GPa), has the electron–phonon coupling constant λ
e−ph = 2.0 and the ratio of critical temperature, T
c, to the Fermi temperature, T
F, in the range of 0.011 ⩽ T
c/T
F ⩽ 0.018. These deduced values are very close to the ones reported for H3S at P = 155–165 GPa (Drozdov et al 2015 Nature
525 73). This means that in all considered scenarios the carbonaceous sulfur hydride 190 K superconductor falls into the unconventional superconductor band in the Uemura plot, where all other highly compressed super-hydride/deuterides are located. It should be noted that our analysis shows that all raw R(T,B) data sets for H
x
(S,C)
y
samples, for which Snider et al (2020 Nature
586 373) reported T
c > 200 K, cannot be characterized as reliable data sources. Thus, independent experimental confirmation/disproof for high-T
c values in the carbonaceous sulfur hydride are required.