In an influential paper of 2002, Babaev, Faddeev and Niemi conjectured that
two-component Ginzburg-Landau (TCGL) theory in three dimensions should support
knot solitons, where the projective equivalence class of the pair of complex
condensate fields [psi_1,psi_2]:R^3 -> CP^1 has non-zero Hopf degree. The
conjecture was motivated by a certain truncation of the TCGL model which
reduced it to the Faddeev-Skyrme model, long known to support knot solitons.
Physically, the truncation amounts to ignoring the coupling between
[psi_1,psi_2] and the supercurrent of the condensates. The current paper
presents a direct test of the validity of this truncation by numerically
tracking the knot solitons as the supercurrent coupling is turned back on. It
is found that the knot solitons shrink and disappear as the true TCGL model is
reached. This undermines the reasoning underlying the conjecture and, when
combined with other negative numerical studies, suggests the conjecture, in its
original form, is very unlikely to be true.Comment: replaced with the published version, with added PACS numbes and
removed a footnote; 12 page