“…In these studies, atomically dispersed CoN x species were not considered as an alternative. Co appears to be privileged for this reactivity on the basis of screening studies, which evaluated benzyl alcohol methyl esterification over a range of M-N-C(iv) catalysts (M = Co, Fe, Cu, V, Cr, Ni, Mn) and M-N-C(i) catalysts (M = Fe, Mn, Co Cu). Co-N-C catalysts competent for esterification have been synthesized by a variety of methods noted in Figure a, including (i), ,,,, (ii), (iii), , (iv), and (v). ,, These studies have observed CoO x nanoparticles, ,,,, metallic Co nanoparticles ,, (often with N–C shells ,,,,, ), and an absence of large metal aggregates that suggests the presence of mononuclear CoN x species. , Quantitative relationships between active site structures and reactivity have not been established.…”