The oxidative stress theory of aging, an expansion of the mitochondrial theory of aging, is based around the idea of a vicious cycle, in which somatic mutations of mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) provoke respiratory chain dysfunction leading to enhanced ROS production and in turn to the accumulation of further mtDNA mutations. Mitochondrial dysfunction and mtDNA mutations are amplified during the course of aging. Recently, results obtained from mtDNA-mutator mice further strengthen the role of mitochondria in the aging process. However, lack of increased oxidative stress in the mtDNA-mutator mice raises doubts in the direct connection of mtDNA mutations with increased ROS production, challenging the oxidative stress theory of aging. The purpose of this short review is to highlight several studies that provide direct evidence that accelerated aging is linked to mtDNA mutations, without an increase in oxidative damage.
The Oxidative Stress Theory of AgingThe 'free radical theory' of aging, formulated 50 years ago by Harman, proposes that aging and associated degenerative diseases can be attributed to deleterious effects of reactive oxygen species (Harman, 1956). This hypothesis has been extensively investigated and debated, but has not yet been clearly validated. Prior to 2004, most investigations took the approach of altering cellular antioxidant capacity and examining the effects on aging-related phenotypes. This approach produced positive results, suggesting that damage from free radicals play some role in aging (Landis & Tower, 2005). A current version of this theory is the 'oxidative stress theory' of aging. The 'oxidative stress theory' states that "A chronic state of oxidative stress exists in cells of aerobic organisms even under normal physiological conditions because of an imbalance of proxidants and antioxidants. This imbalance results in a steady-state accumulation of oxidative damage in a variety of macromolecules. Oxidative damage increases during aging, which results in a progressive loss in the functional efficiency of various cellular processes." (Sohal & Weindruch, 1996) Although reactive oxygen species production is a significant component of the proposed 'oxidative stress theory', this theory is consistent with and expands the 'mitochondrial theory' of aging. The main tenet of the 'mitochondrial theory' predicts that a 'vicious cycle' within the mitochondria contributes to the aging process. Briefly, components of the vicious cycle are: (1) normal metabolism causes reactive oxygen species production by the electron transport chain; (2) reactive oxygen species production induces damage to phospholipids, proteins, and nucleic acids in mitochondria; (3) reactive oxygen species-induced mitochondrial DNA Contact information: LaDora V. Thompson,