In marine waters, ubiquitous reactive oxygen species (ROS) drive biogeochemical cycling of metals and carbon. Marine phytoplankton produce the ROS superoxide (O
2
−
) extracellularly and can be a dominant source of O
2
−
in natural aquatic systems. However, the cellular regulation, biological functioning, and broader ecological impacts of extracellular O
2
−
production by marine phytoplankton remain mysterious. Here, we explored the regulation and potential roles of extracellular O
2
−
production by a noncalcifying strain of the cosmopolitan coccolithophorid
Emiliania huxleyi
, a key species of marine phytoplankton that has not been examined for extracellular O
2
−
production previously. Cell-normalized extracellular O
2
−
production was the highest under presumably low-stress conditions during active proliferation and inversely related to cell density during exponential growth phase. Removal of extracellular O
2
−
through addition of the O
2
−
scavenger superoxide dismutase (SOD), however, increased growth rates, growth yields, cell biovolume, and photosynthetic efficiency (
F
v
/F
m
) indicating an overall physiological improvement. Thus, the presence of extracellular O
2
−
does not directly stimulate
E. huxleyi
proliferation, as previously suggested for other phytoplankton, bacteria, fungi, and protists. Extracellular O
2
−
production decreased in the dark, suggesting a connection with photosynthetic processes. Taken together, the tight regulation of this stress independent production of extracellular O
2
−
by
E. huxleyi
suggests that it could be involved in fundamental photophysiological processes.